Nigeria
-
Refrain from Sins-Prof. Olagoke to Nigerian Leaders and their Followers
- By solomon2day
- On 19/07/2021
- In News
The government at all levels has been called upon to refrain from sins to ensure the promotion of a sanitised and secured society.
This call was made by the Founder, Spiritual Head, and Grand Imam of Shafaudeen-in-Islam Worldwide,Wakajaiye, Ibadan, Oyo state Nigeria, Prof. Sabitu Olagoke contained in his Eid 'L Kabir message.
''As we celebrate Eid 'L Kabir, let the Government at all levels and its people refrain from sins but focus on the onerous task of restoring sanity, security, and sustainable development in Nigeria,'' Prof. Olagoke counseled. -
COVID 19 Delta Variant-Govt not doing Enough-Ex-Officio TUC
- By solomon2day
- On 13/07/2021
- In News
The Government at all levels is not doing enough to preventing the third wave of the deadly coronavirus(Indian variant) from causing avoidable havoc.
This assertion was made in a chat with Poverty Line on Monday by an Ex-Officio of the Oyo State Council of the Trade Union Congress(TUC), who is also a former Chairman of the union, Comrade Andrew Emelieze.
''Considering the devasting effects of the coronavirus, the Indian variant, the government at all levels in Nigeria has not been proactive by ensuring that enough is done to avoid a crisis situation of casualties. Similarly, Nigerians are also complacent by refusing to abide by the stipulated protocols, we must change this attitude and guard against the fatal health condition'', Comrade Emelieze warned. -
Stop your Evil Acts to Avoid the Wrath of God-Cleric to kidnappers and other criminals.
- By solomon2day
- On 08/07/2021
- In News
Kidnappers and other categories of criminals in Nigeria have been advised to desist from their evil acts to avoid the wrath of God.
This advice of given by a Christian cleric, Pastor Opeyemi Ajayi.
''My advice to kidnappers, terrorists, and other categories of criminals is for them to desist from their evil acts to avoid the wrath of God. They should turn a new leaf, if not the wrath of God would eventually consume them. If history is anything to go by they are already treading the path of destruction.
Also, the Government at all levels should make life more meaningful and bearable for Nigerians'', Pastor Ajayi concluded. -
Beyond the People's Reach
- By solomon2day
- On 28/06/2021
- In Special Report
Strangely, poverty alleviation and reduction seem not to be on the priority list of the state actors at all levels of government.
The measures in the past years have failed woefully to empower Nigerians to be economically productive, with the sole focus of improving their quality of life.Transfer Money with Wise
Poverty alleviation programs do not cut across all sectors of the economy, failing to adequately address the problems of low economic growth and high poverty incidence.
Millions of Nigerians insist that beneficiaries of government advertised empowerment programs are not known to them.
The insecurity everywhere in Nigeria has foreclosed any way forward in the agricultural sector.
indeed, unemployment, access to affordable housing, satisfactory Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary health care delivery, quality education, potable water supply, and regular electricity supply among others, constitute the urgent needs of poor Nigerians, who are in the majority are beyond reach. And a result has brought about hunger, poverty, and stunted economic growth. -
The Steady Drift
- By solomon2day
- On 25/10/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Those in security circles around the globe insist that a government that is responsible and accountable to its people does not give deadlines, ultimatums, and time limits to criminals.
They go on to attribute insurmountable insecurity in several countries to either the covert involvement of the government itself, its admirers, well-wishers, or agents.
These personalities stress that such a government must have identified and isolated fifth columnists within its ranks before it ever thinks of commencing a maximum cleansing of the criminals impeding good governance.
But sadly, this is not the case in Nigeria, as unfolding events have proven beyond reasonable doubt.
Nigerians have concluded that the government does not have ready solutions to the kidnappings, killings, and other violent crimes, while they daily pray for God’s intervention.
Even the security summits that have already been organized in the past several days by some interest groups, with some state governors in attendance, have been seen by Nigerians as mere jamborees.
With the continuous spate of kidnappings, killings, and other violent crimes not abating, Nigerians have come to the conclusion that the country is already in a state of emergency, though the government is yet to make such a declaration.
They attribute the agitation for the establishment of state police by a few self-serving individuals to the uninformed perspectives of these individuals.
Of worry are the great difficulties experienced by government praise singers and bootlickers to accept the hard fact that the present administration can no longer address the overwhelming insecurity in the land without reaching out to personalities and institutions it had hitherto ignored.
What is the situation?
The present administration continues in its condolence culture, for which the citizens have known it for.
For how long shall this go on? Nobody knows.
-
The Steady Drift
- By solomon2day
- On 25/10/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Those in security circles around the globe insist that a government that is responsible and accountable to its people does not give deadlines, ultimatums, and time limits to criminals.
They go on to attribute insurmountable insecurity in several countries to either the covert involvement of the government itself, its admirers, well-wishers, or agents.
These personalities stress that such a government must have identified and isolated fifth columnists within its ranks before it ever thinks of commencing a maximum cleansing of the criminals impeding good governance.
But sadly, this is not the case in Nigeria, as unfolding events have proven beyond reasonable doubt.
Nigerians have concluded that the government does not have ready solutions to the kidnappings, killings, and other violent crimes, while they daily pray for God’s intervention.
Even the security summits that have already been organized in the past several days by some interest groups, with some state governors in attendance, have been seen by Nigerians as mere jamborees.
With the continuous spate of kidnappings, killings, and other violent crimes not abating, Nigerians have come to the conclusion that the country is already in a state of emergency, though the government is yet to make such a declaration.
They attribute the agitation for the establishment of state police by a few self-serving individuals to the uninformed perspectives of these individuals.
Of worry are the great difficulties experienced by government praise singers and bootlickers to accept the hard fact that the present administration can no longer address the overwhelming insecurity in the land without reaching out to personalities and institutions it had hitherto ignored.
What is the situation?
The present administration continues in its condolence culture, for which the citizens have known it for.
For how long shall this go on? Nobody knows.
-
Wanted Urgently-Qualified and Experienced Teachers
- By solomon2day
- On 20/10/2024
- In Update with Solomon
The first term of a new session across private and public secondary schools is underway in Nigeria. Parents and guardians are out there, doing whatever it takes to ensure that their children and wards continue their education.
Curiously, in a number of major cities and state including Ibadan, Oyo state;private and public school proprietors, proprietresses and owners of schools are still in urgent need of qualified and experienced teachers to justify the ridiculous fees they charge.
Nobody knows what happened to the workforce.
However, the underlying challenges could be traced to the action and inaction of the government, staff of the ministry of Education and the law enforcement agencies among others.
Indeed, the policy of education of a number of state governments is defective, this is in addition to the unwillingness of pupils and students to learn.
The behavior and activities of pupils and students on the streets of Ibadan are a good reflection of the bleak future that lies ahead of young people in Nigeria.
-
Young People Drift into the Iredeemable Circle
- By solomon2day
- On 13/10/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Vital literacy indicators reveal a deplorable condition in the Nigerian educational system.
Indeed, the adult literacy rate is embarrassing, while the number of out-of-school children has reached an all-time high rate.
Trailing the falling standard of education at all levels, is the ever-increasing rate of drop-outs today.
With particular reference to the Primary, Secondary and Tertiary levels of education, cultism, gangster ism and prostitution have become the popular choice for undergraduates, students and pupils in educational institutions across the states of the federation.
Shortage of qualified teachers, lack of teaching aids, recreational facilities in schools and basic infrastructure are just a few among the sore points of schools in Nigeria.
Of serious worry are the poor sanitation, overcrowding in classrooms, poor conditions of service for teachers, which has resulted in the poor quality of teaching and poor quality of classroom products.
All put together, have become negative signposts of the school environment.
Sadly, poor educational management, a reflection of the poor inter-sectoral allocation, multiplicity of agencies with duplicated functions and inadequate coordination, have all made education administration in most states questionable and fraudulent.
The weak support for education by governments at all levels is a manifestation of the ineptitude of government officials.
The government’s deliberate neglect of the management of the education sector may eventually result in the total collapse of the public education system.
The shortcomings of government have heightened the stakes for private investors and made the education sector very lucrative.
Sadly, the complicity of the government and society, over the years, has prompted the uncontrollable behavior and acts of young people particularly in Ibadan, capital of Oyo state and other major cities in Nigeria.
Surprisingly, the adults watch helplessly as this category of Nigerians drift into the irredeemable circle.
With the profit motive as the major emphasis and driving force, educational institutions are now germinating like pure water factories in every nook and cranny of Nigeria, while at the same time, such institutions are turning out educationally unacceptable products.
With all these in mind, Nigerians are urgently asking :
Can governments at all levels make education available, relevant, accessible and affordable to all Nigerians ?
Can governments at all levels ensure immediate and long term social and economic returns from education ?
Are public educational institutions, considering their present state, competent to produce a skilled workforce ? Answers to these questions are in the public domain with stakeholders vigorously avoiding these questions.
-
The Mao Zedong Model
- By solomon2day
- On 08/10/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Mao Zedong, popularly known as Chairman Mao, was successful with his noble goals for China through despotic means.
His leadership was severe, dictatorial and personalized.
For as long as Chairman Mao's Cultural Revolution lasted, thousands of Chinese died of starvation and inhuman labor.
Mao and his co-travelers argued that the same was the price their people had to pay for re-education.
This brand of governance ensured the extermination of the heroes of the civil war and the old party chieftains by the President's armed squad.
Chairman Mao is perhaps the role model of those who hold sway in Nigeria today.
Indeed, the Kaduna state Governor, Mallam Nasir El Rufai is among several other political office holders, who adore President Muhammadu Buhari.
Those in support of this argument insist that on a number of occasions, the Kaduna state Governor knelt down to greet and/or consult with the President. They maintain that this is only a sign of respect in the traditional African setting.
However, those against this order of things, stress that the underlying factors revolve around hypocrisy and boot licking.
Nigerians are yet to stop complaining of constitutional breaches and the unabated trampling of the rule of law in the dust, without noticeable changes by the powers that be.
From recent events in the country, the economic reform programs of the All Progressives Congress(APC) led government at the center and in the states, are modeled along the thinking of a free market economy.
It is doubtful if the government, in most recent times, has managed the economy for the benefit of Nigerians.
Of worry is the state of manufacturing industries, which could be said to be epileptic, even as food security is a mirage, insecurity is the chorus everywhere, while crude oil remains the major hope of the present administration.
Interestingly, the future growth of the Nigerian economy rests comfortably on diversification and focus on visionary and creative people-friendly economic policies, although the government still over-relies and over-depends on crude oil to fund its programs.
Can the present administration turn around the troubled economy ? Nobody knows.
-
The People lament
- By solomon2day
- On 28/09/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Millions of Nigerians are complaining that hunger and poverty have taken root nationwide.
The insecurity in the land has disabled the productivity of farmers in different parts of the country, while political office holders have been overwhelmed by their pecuniary and self-centered interests.
State actors insist that millions of farmers have benefited from the agricultural subsidies of the government, but the prohibitive cost of food items punctures this claim. For a considerable period of time now, the import of agricultural products has far outweighed exports, confirming the insinuation that state actors are insincere and about the true situation of things in the agricultural sector.
-
Lessons in Insecurity : The Nigeria Model
- By solomon2day
- On 04/09/2024
- In Update with Solomon
Adolf Hitler labeled the extermination of the Jews in Europe,''the Final Solution'', while the military dictatorship in Argentina, which embarked on an unprecedented killing of its citizens, code named the same ''The Process of National Reorganization''.
The activities of bandits, insurgents and herdsmen in Nigeria which have claimed thousands of lives are similar to the above-mentioned.
Between 1976 and 1983, millions of citizens lost their lives in Argentina.
Death squads operating under secret circumstances and under the cover of the state, murdered about 11,000 people, which is now described as ''The Disappeared''.
Two million people escaped persecution, while hundreds of babies born to ''The Disappeared'' were either sold, bartered or murdered.
Indeed, happenings in different states of Nigeria, including, Borno, Benue, Taraba and Plateau and Zamfafra states, among several others, indicate the Government's adequate knowledge of the situation, while unabated killings go on.
The relocation of the Inspector General of Police to Benue state, one of the troubled spots then, did not reverse the status quo.
On March 23, 1976, General Jourge Videla, Head of the Argentine Army, overthrew the Government of Isabelita Peron, a former nightclub dancer. In this country, no civilian government has completed its tenure, except for Juan Peron, who spent only one tenure in office.
However, in Nigeria, a two term governor of Lagos state, is in charge, even though the country still experiences symptoms of economic hunger, poverty, mass unemployment, corruption and a high level of insecurity.
The Ejercito Revolucionario de Pueblo and the Montoneros, leftists, took to kidnapping and killings to express their displeasure over bad governance in Argentina. In Nigeria, kidnappings and killings have gone on unabated. Political watchers put the blame at the doorstep of government.
Presently, Nigerians are worried over the government's inaction, as the country gradually slides into anarchy.
Sadly, the open stealing of smart phones has become bibg business in Ibadan, Oyo state and other states of the federation
Accusing fingers are being pointed at political office holders who have failed to deliver the dividends of democracy.
Interestingly, the body language of the National Assembly, is an indication that the lawmakers are yet to realize the need for the entrenchment of the rule of law and due process in the polity, just as impunity is now the order of the day
In 2009, the Defense Minister of Madagascar, Cecile Manorohanta, resigned her appointment on the grounds that she would not be part of a government that kills its citizens.
Also, the people of Madagascar vigorously opposed the attempts by President Marc Ravalomanana to lease one million acres of their land to a Korean firm, Daewoo, for intensive farming.
The people have deep ties with their land and, as a result, view the President's action as a betrayal.
The same scenario is playing out in Nigeria.
The insecurity in the land has made foreign investment impossible, while the disenfranchised and poor majority look into the gloomy future for reprieve.
-
In the Interest of Digital Literacy
- By solomon2day
- On 23/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
In Nigeria, millions of citizens, most especially the poor and vulnerable, remain without internet access.
For a long time, internet users have had to put up with very substandard services.
This is as a result of inefficiency and inadequate infrastructure.
Sadly, most of those who are fortunate to have internet access use it negatively.
Indeed, digital literacy is a major challenge across the country and this has translated to limited internet use in most sectors of the economy.
Youths have taken to crime due to the attitude of the leadership at all levels of government, while pornographic content has exposed minors to immoral acts.
Of worry, is the lack of funding for research and infrastructure for Information and Communication Technology(ICT) by today's leadership.
The Backbone
The Nigerian youth involved in crime is not acting alone, some of those in positions of authority are his or her backbone.
This becomes glaring when an individual takes a keen interest in unfolding events.
-
The Leadership Challenge
- By solomon2day
- On 20/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
What would aid good governance is not in place. Rather, unnecessary criticism and condemnation of trailing the activities of Those-in-Charge visible are setbacks.
Unguarded remarks, utterances and reckless statements and comments amplify the leadership abilities of an individual, positively or negatively.
Sadly, the trend among leaders in most climes, is to take positions on sensitive issues without thoughtful analysis of available facts.
Indeed, paying attention to details and aspects considered to be irrelevant ensures a very high degree of intelligent fairness that is essential for success in leadership.
Mao Zedong, popularly known as Chairman Mao, was successful with his noble goals for China through despotic means.
His leadership was severe, dictatorial and personalized.
For as long as Chairman Mao's Cultural Revolution lasted, thousands of Chinese died of starvation and inhuman labor.
Mao and his co-travelers argued that the same was the price their people had to pay for re-education.
This brand of governance ensured the extermination of the heroes of the civil war and the old party chieftains by the President's armed squad.
Chairman Mao is perhaps the role model of those who hold sway in Nigeria today.
Indeed, the Senate President is among several other political office holders who adore President Ahmed Tinubu.
Those in support of this argument insist that the lawmaker is a regular visitor to Aso Rock for unknown reasons.
However, those against this order of things, stress that the underlying factors revolve around hypocrisy and boot licking.
Nigerians are yet to stop complaining of constitutional breaches and the unabated trampling of the rule of law in the dust, without noticeable changes by the powers that be.
From recent events in the country, the economic reform programs of the All Progressives Congress(APC) led government at the center and in the states, are modeled along the thinking of a free market economy.
It is doubtful if the government, in most recent times, has managed the economy for the benefit of Nigerians.
Of worry is the state of manufacturing industries, which could be said to be epileptic, even as food security is a mirage, insecurity is the chorus everywhere, while crude oil remains the major hope of the present administration.
Interestingly, the future growth of the Nigerian economy rests comfortably on diversification and focus on visionary and creative people-friendly economic policies, although the government still over-relies and over-depends on crude oil to fund its programs.
Can the present administration turn around the troubled economy ? Nobody knows. Donate
-
The Perpetual Absence of Visionary Leadership
- By solomon2day
- On 19/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
The improvement in the system of transportation, to a very great measure, increases the physical extent and economic size of a country.
However, in the Nigerian context, a number of factors have negatively affected the transport system and this has resulted in an astronomical rise in the prices of goods and services beyond the reach of a majority of the population.
The prohibitive transportation costs coupled with the multiple taxation across the country and the unabating insecurity have all succeeded in ensuring that Nigerians remain in a perpetual state of hunger and poverty.
Curiously, levels of government have channeled generated revenue from multiple taxes, unproductively, to real estate, while Nigerians continue to daily count their landed property losses.
Indeed, the government at all levels have always contended with inadequate financial organization and the relevant knowledge.
Sadly, economic stagnation is now a major characteristic in most cities that are contending with overpopulation. Petty trading and individual investments in consumables have become the preference of the people, in the absence of proactive, visionary leadership.
-
Calming Frayed Nerves
- By solomon2day
- On 15/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
The burden of a nation is too multi-dimensional for a single power broker to manage.
There are entrenched interests in the military, security services, a section of the judiciary and also the bureaucracy, while the population at large remains distraught and impoverished.
Indeed, to inherit a badly managed and shattered economy is disturbing to those who know what is in stock aside from the high level of insecurity.
Those-in-Charge need not feign ignorance about the pressing issues at stake, but go all out to tackle the issues, even as reservations, doubts and suspicions grow among the populace by the day.
The Situation
It is now very glaring that millions of Nigerians-outside the workforce- are contending with hunger, poverty, unemployment and a number of other hardships.
This has resulted into a sizable number the citizens embracing crime as a means to an end.
Those -in-charge are only scratching the surface while the situation deteriorates daily.
-
Living with Evil
- By solomon2day
- On 11/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
The evil deeds of some state governors are limiting factors when they involve interfacing with law enforcement agencies.
Indeed, the situation has become so bad to the extent that the people no longer trust political office holders to guarantee the safety of lives and property.
Sadly, a number of state governors are very reluctant to move against cultists who have continued to wreak havoc in the affected states.
Interaction is preferably by representation, because a lot is still hidden, that is gradually coming to light.
Indeed, the evil that men do lives with them and has become their shadows.
No responsible law-abiding and right-thinking Nigerian will subscribe to calls by some individuals to cooperate with criminals. Perhaps -
Good Governance
- By solomon2day
- On 10/08/2024
- In Update with Solomon
It is to the knowledge of millions of Nigerians that the basic social-economic institutions have been destroyed.
The challenge now is how to fix the nation's health, education, judiciary and other institutions or ensure a satisfactory turn around.
In developed countries, economic activities are the backbone of politics and, as such, distortions or reversal of economic policies or long-term strategic national objectives are rare.
Sadly, little or nothing has been achieved to guarantee a good economic foundation, which ought to be the back-rest of politics.
This is reflected in the awkward power-sharing, power rotation and inequitable distribution of resources and good governance.
The kind of economic reforms by the government would go a long way in determining if Those-in-Charge are neophytes in the Herculean task of governance.
Aiding and Abetting Criminals
For so long, cultists such as one Wolex and Lekan Adewale of 8 Kehinde Aderibigbe steet, Olorunsogo, Molete, Ibadan, Oyo state, Nigeria, have been terrorizing, robbing and attacking innocent Nigerians in the above-mentioned community and so many others. Although the law enforcement agencies feign ignorance, the confidence exuded by the criminals, who have continued to commit heinous and grievous crimes with impunity, exposes the deep involvement of the police in violent crimes, not only in Oyo state but in different parts of the country.
-
Appeal Court Judgment 2-Onyendu Ndigbo, Chief Alloy Obi
- By solomon2day
- On 09/08/2024
- In Special Report
evidence led had disclosed the cause of action. He added that the evidence elicited from the defence witness, particularly DW2, showed that as at June, 2010 there was only one person recognized as the Eze Ndigbo or Onyendu of Oyo State and that was Chief Dr, Alex Anozie (1st Claimant); that that confirmed the cause of action of the Respondents.
On the claim of Appellants that 1st Appellant was elected and not selected as Onyendu, whereas the Respondents were complaining about the selection of 1st Appellant as Onyendu, Counsel for Respondent cited the case of Marwa Vs Nyako (2012) 6 NWLR (Pt.1269) 199 at 357 to say that:
"An election means the process of
choosing by popular votes a candidate."
He argued that selection is also a process of choosing a candidate and the word election is all embracing and also includes selection. He referred to the finding of the trial Court on Pages 1098 - 1099 of the Records to show that what was clearly in issue was the title of Onyendu Ndigbo, whether the claim of 1st Claimant to the title as being elected by Igbo community Development Association (ICDA), or that of 1st Appellant as being elected by Igbo General Assembly, should stand - that is, the dispute was about the leadership of Igbos in Ibadan and Oyo State, via the title of Onyendu Ndigbo, who was entitled to
Occupy the office.
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR. WO. UGWU H.O.D, LITIGATION
1876724
Page 31
He urged us to resolve the Issue against Appellants.
On Issue 2, Counsel said the whole attack by the
Appellants was about the style of and manner by which the trial
Court writes judgment. He said that the style of writing judgment is unique to each Judge. He relied on Ogolo Vs Ogolo (2003) 18 NWLR (Pt.853) 494 at 523-524; Abeje Vs Apeke (2014) ALL FWLR (Pt.715) 376.
In this case, at hand, Counsel said the trial Court made
findings of fact which were not in dispute from the pleadings of
the parties and evidence led, and that was all, as shown on
Pages 1097 to 1098 of the Records. He said that the trial Court
dwelt, extensively, on the facts and evidence before it, as per
the pleadings, in reaching its conclusions; that the decision was
not perverse as alleged by the Appellants. He relied on the case
of Romaine Vs Romaine (1992) LPELR-2953 SC; Belgore Vs Ahmed (2013) 8 NWLR (Pt.1355) 63.
Counsel said the trial Court was right, when it did not
ascribe any probative value to DW2's evidence; that the evidence
wall all fabrication and the witness was economical with the
truth.
Counsel said that the Respondents were entitled to the grant of the 1st and 2nd Reliefs, as they were proved by evidence led by PW1, PW2 and PW3 and corroborated by the DW3 - as
per Page 955 of the Records of Appeal, when he said:
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR, W. O. UGWU H.O.D. L
IGATION
Page 32
"I can see Exhibit 2. It was written by Ohaneze Ndigbo to the 1st Claimant on 31/8/2010 acknowledging him as the only Onyendu Ndigbo of Oyo State. I cannot remember whether there was any election after 31/8/2010 in Oyo State among Igbos."
Counsel said the Respondents were entitled to take benefit
of evidence by the Appellants that supported them
(Respondents). He relied on Gaji Vs Paye 14 NSCQLR (Pt.1)
613.
On Issue 3, Counsel said that Appeal can only lie against a
ratio decidendi of a Court, not against an obiter. He relied on
Section 243(A) of the 1999 Constitution of FRN and the case of
Dalhatu Vs Turaki (2003) 15 NWLR (Pt.843) 310 at 350;
Wilson Vs Osin (1988) 4 NWLR (Pt.88) 324.
Counsel said that the comments of the trial Judge which
Appellants seek to appeal against in ground 9 of the Appeal, vis
a vis, the obiter of the Judge on Ohaneze Ndigbo and the South
East Council of Traditional Rulers, cannot be appealed against.
He also relied on Ngige Vs Obi (2006) ALL FWLR (Pt.330) 1041 at 1141; Buhari Vs Obasanjo (2005) 13 NWLR (Pt.941) 1 at 126-127.
On the Issue of not joining the South East Council of
Traditional Rulers and Ohaneze Ndigbo as parties, but making
orders that affect them, Counsel said the two bodies were aware
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEA IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR. W. O. UGWU H.O.D. LITIGATION
Page 33
of the Suit, but preferred to only give evidence on behalf of the parties; that, of the 8 witnesses called by the parties, 3 of them were from the Ohaneze Ndigbo and South East Traditional Rulers Council; that they stood by and watched the parties slug it out. He relied on the case of Ogundiani Vs Araba (1978) 11 NSCC 334, and asserted again that the comments made by the trial Judge against the South East Council of Traditional Rulers and Ohaneze Ndigbo were simply obiter, not ratio decidendi.
On the submission of Appellants that the trial Court did not consider the exhibits tendered by Appellants, Counsel for Respondents said that the exhibits complained of, particularly 21-29, 34-35 were dumped on the Court and the Court has no duty to consider documents dumped on the Court, that it will amount to breach of fair hearing, if the trial Court examined such documents in chamber. He relied on the case of Terab Vs Lawan (1992) 3 NWLR (Pt.231) 569, which requires a party who relies on documents in proof of his case to specifically relate each of such documents to that part of his case in respect of which the document is being tendered.
He urged us to resolve the Issues against Appellants and to dismiss the Appeal.
Appellants file a lengthy bulky Reply Brief which appears to be a rehearse of the entire arguments in the Amended Brief. Of course, a Reply brief can only be justified, where it tackles a new/fresh points of law by Respondent in his brief, which were
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR. WO. UGWU H.O.D. LITIGATION
126......
Page 34
not raised in the Appellants' brief or contemplated therein. See
ABC (Transport Company) Ltd Vs Miss Sunmi Omotoye (2019) LPELR-47829 (SC); Adedeji & Ors Vs CBN &
Anor (2022) LPELR-59629 (SC).
RESOLUTION OF ISSUES
I think the real Issues thrown up in this Appeal are two,
namely:
(1) Whether the learned trial Court was seised of jurisdiction to entertain the Suit, considering the issue of locus standi of the Respondents to complain against the election of the 1st Appellant as Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan by the Igbo General Assembly (IGA) and whether they disclosed sufficient cause of action in the circumstances of this
case.
(2) Whether the trial Court was right to hold that 1st Respondent was the Onyendu Ndigbo instead of the 1st Appellant, in the face
face of
of the
intervention and decision of the South East Council of Traditional Rulers and
Ohaneze
Ndigbo
which
intervention/decision the learned trial
Judge greatly deprecated condemned.
I shall take the Two Issues, together.
CA/IB/116/2014
and
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
CAMRUE
BARR. W. O. UGWU H.O.D. LITIGATION
MATE
Page 35
A brief facts of this case at the trial Court, shows that
Appellants and Respondents were all of Igbo extraction living
and doing businesses in Oyo State and they organized
themselves to select or elect their leader or Eze in Ibadan the
(Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State). They however broke up into factions in the cause of selecting their said leader. While the Respondents belonged to a group known as Igbo Community Development Association (ICDA) led by former 1st
Respondent, Dr. Alex Anozie, the Appellants had their group -
Igbo Community of Oyo State (ICOS), led by one Dr. Oramadike.
The former 1st Respondent, (late Dr. Alex Anozie) claimed to have been selected as the Onyendu Ndigbo by the Igbo Community Development Association (ICDA), in 1997 and that the said selection was ratified by the Ohaneze Ndigbo, the umbrella socio-cultural organization of the Igbos. But the Igbo Community of Oyo State (ICOS), led by one Dr. Oramadike did
not accept the claims of Dr. Alex Anozie and ICDA and rather
opted for the 1st Appellant.
The ensuing tussle and crises for the selection of the Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State attracted the
intervention of the South East Council of Traditional Rulers in the year, 2009, July 14th, which resulted in the dissolution of the two
Igbo groups the ICDA and ICOS, along with their leaderships,
-
and Claimants to the title of Onyendu Ndigbo were barred from using it.
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAC IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR, W. O. Uewu
H.O.D. LITIGATION
Page 36
Appellants claimed to have formed another Igbo
organization in Oyo State and Ibadan, called Igbo General
Assembly (IGA), upon the dissolution of the ICDA and ICOS, and
that it was the said Igbo General Assembly that elected the 1st
Appellant as the Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State in
2010.
That election gave rise to this case, as the Respondents sought the order of the Court that 1st Respondent (Dr. Alex
Anozie) remained the recognized Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and
Oyo State, having been elected democratically in 1997, before
the 14/7/2009, when the South East Council of Traditional Rulers
intervened. They also sought orders declaring the steps taken by Appellants towards the selection (of election) of 1st Appellant by 2nd - 6th Defendants contrary to Igbo customs and traditions and contrary to the Constitution of the Ohaneze Ndigbo, and so null and void. They also sought an order to set aside the selection of the 1st Appellant as Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State and to restrain him and the Appellants from parading as the Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State.
The trial Court had agreed with the Plaintiffs (Respondents herein) and made the Orders sought. Hence this Appeal.
I must start by stating the obvious, that by our laws, particularly the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended), the right to form an association, and forming of organisations and bodies to pursue any common CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION
CERTIFIED TRUM COPY
BARR, WO. UGWU
LITIGATION
Page 37
lawful interest, is entrenched and where such organisations or
bodies are formed the persons coming together can take
whatever name(s) and leadership they desire, within the
confines of the rules and regulations they give to themselves,
otherwise called - their internal Constitutions.
That is the purport of Section 40 of the Constitution of the
Federal Republic of Nigeria, which states:
"Every person shall be entitled to assemble freely and associate with other persons, and in particular he may form or belong to any political party, trade union or any other association for the protection of his interest; provided that the provisions of this Section shall not derogate from the powers conferred by this Constitution on the Independent National Electoral Commission, with respect to political parties to which that commission does not accord recognition."
I believe all the socio-cultural and ethnic/tribal associations and voluntary organisations derive their existence, relevance and
vibes from this law. In the case of Eronini & Ors Vs Eronini & Ors (2013) LPELR-20651 (CA) my Lord, Abba Aji, JCA (as she then was) stated on the right of individuals to form or join any association, freely, without being forced or coerced, as
follows:
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARK W.GUGWU H.O.G. LITIGATION
Page 38
It is trite that every person resident in Nigeria has a right to go about his or her lawful business unmolested or unhampered by anyone else be it a government functionary or a private individual. Thus, the Court will frawn upon any manifestation of arbitrary power assumed by any person or authority over the life or property of another even if that other is suspected of having breached some law or regulation. People must never take the law into their hands by attempting to enforce what they consider to be their right or entitlement, Per Ikongbeh JCA (of blessed memory) in Nkpa vs. Nkume (2001) 6 NWLR (PT 710) 543 at 560. In fact, in the instant case, the Respondents were being harassed and molested and prevented from lawfully associating with each under a purported authority which the Respondents do not possess. The Appellants should have tackled the situation in a leadership like manner and not show aggrandizement. In his contributory judgment in Nkpa vs. Nkume (Supra) at page 564, Pats Acholonu, JCA said as follows: "Time was when the law governing the native community was force of custom good or bad and whether repugnant or not. Now in the 21st century we are
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION
CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
TRUE
BARR. W. O. UGWU H.O.D. LITIGATION
DATE
1076724...
Page 39
governed by a living law - the Constitution fashioned after the Constitution of older democracies. No one can force or coerce any to join club, society or group that he does not intend or wish to be a member. It is an affront and infraction of the Constitutional right to use old age custom that has now been relegated to morbidity to make one acquiesce or become a member to a body that he or she despises. It is atrophy."
See also the case of Mbanefo Vs Molokwu (2008) LPELR
-
3696 CA, where this Court held in furtherance of the Section 40 of the 1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria that the Court would not ordinarily interfere with decision of voluntary associations. It held:
Agbalanze Onitsha is a voluntary association to which the appellant belonged. It is entitled under its Constitution to decide for itself what it wants and to organize itself and a Court cannot tell such a voluntary association how it must be organized. If any member of such an association does not like its decision it is open to such a member to resign. See Section 6 (c) of Exhibit 'A'. Any society or association, comprising of members who voluntarily join it, is entitled to come to any decision which they like.
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR. W. O. UGWU H.O.D. LIGATION
Page 40
It must be said loud and clear, the party or association or even a club, to which any person belongs is supreme so far as its affairs go. See Macdongal Vs. Gardiner (1875) 1 Ch.D. 13 at 25 per Millish, L.J." Per TSAMIYA,
JCA (P.29, paras. B-E)
Thus, where a voluntary organisation sets out its objectives and goals as per its constitution, the members thereof are bound thereto, and the same objectives and goals or rules of the organisation cannot be forced on non-members of the organisation. Moreover, other voluntary organisations with similar objectives and goals are permitted to operate, within the same space, while ensuring that their aspirations are sought and pursued, peacefully, even if competitively in rival struggle, without endangering the public peace.
And where
where a voluntary organisation or association subordinates itself to another larger or parent body, as per their laws and rules, it cannot defy the orders and directions of the said larger or parent organisation to which it submits to, in my opinion.
In this case, at hand, what appears interesting and intriguing is the fact that both the Respondents and Appellants, in their pleadings and evidence, subordinated their voluntary organisations, which produced their Leaders and the Eze, known as "Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State" to some
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION
CERTIFIED TRUE/COPY
TRUEL C
BARR. W. O. UGWU
H.O.D. UTICATION
107.6724
DATE.....
Page 41
larger or parent organisations namely the South-East Council of Traditional Rulers and Ohaneze Ndigbo, and they looked forward to being guided, directed, and their decisions ratified or
sanctioned by the said South-East Council of Traditional Rulers and Ohaneze Ndigbo.
In their pleadings and reliefs sought and even evidence led,
the Respondents (as Claimants) clearly disclosed their romance
and obeysance to the customs and traditions of the Igbos
(which, of course, are custodied by the South-East Council of Traditional Rulers, and also sought the protection of Ohaneze Ndigbo as the umbrella organisation of all people of Igbo
extraction, world-wide.
For instance, in their Relief one, Respondents, in asserting
their right as Igbo Community Development Association (ICDA),
to produce the Onyendu Ndigbo of Ibadan and Oyo State, alleged that they democratically election of 1st Respondent (Dr.
Alex Anozie) in 1997, "subsequent ratification of the
election swearing-in and authority of the 1st Claimant
(was done) (was given) by the Ohaneze Ndigbo in the
year 2000."
In Relief 3, Respondents sought a Declaration that all
acts and steps taken by the Defendants towards the
selection and proposed installation of the 1st Defendant by the 2nd to 6th Defendants are contrary to Igbo
CA/IB/116/2014
COURT OF APPEAL IBADAN DIVISION CERTIFIED TRUE COPY
BARR. W. O. UGWU H.O.D. LITIGATION
Page 42
Customs and Traditions and the Constitution of Ohaneze Ndigbo and is therefore null and void."